Shopping Cart
Quick view
Login
Search for products on our site
See more
  • HOME
  • SHOP
    • COOKIES
    • SANDWICHES
    • GRUBHUB
    • DOORDASH
    • MERCHANDISE
    • SMALL RETAILERS
  • CUSTOM HALFMOONS
  • GRUBHUB
  • DOORDASH
  • OUR STORY
  • BLOG
Account
  • Log in
  • Create account
Hemstroughts Bakery (Est. 1920)
  • HOME
  • SHOP
    • COOKIES
    • SANDWICHES
    • GRUBHUB
    • DOORDASH
    • MERCHANDISE
    • SMALL RETAILERS
  • CUSTOM HALFMOONS
  • GRUBHUB
  • DOORDASH
  • OUR STORY
  • BLOG
  • Search
  • Account
  • Cart
Hemstroughts Bakery (Est. 1920)
Cart

Shop

Hemstrought’s, famous for the “original Halfmoon Cookie” has not changed the recipe since 1920.

Cookies are baked from scratch every morning with all natural ingredients and hand frosted with a chocolate fudge and vanilla buttercream frosting.

Although there are many renditions of our cookie circulating in the market (maybe you have heard of “black and whites”?), none can compare to the decadent, but light taste and soft texture of our original recipe.

Taste the cookie that started it all. 

 Please note: All orders ship Monday - Wednesday.

Quick view

Sprinkle Butter Cookies

$15.00

( / )

Halfmoon Chocolate Cookie
Quick view

NEW! Single Chocolate Halfmoon Cookie

$2.50

( / )

Black & White buttercream cookie on a vanilla bottom
Quick view

NEW! Single Vanilla Halfmoon Cookie

$2.50

( / )

BLACK AND WHITE BUTTERCREAM COOKIE
Quick view

Hemstrought's Original Halfmoon Cookies - Vanilla Bottoms

From $6.00

( / )

Black & White Buttercream Cookies
Quick view

Hemstrought's Original Halfmoon Cookies - Chocolate Bottoms

From $6.00

( / )

black and white buttercream cookie
Quick view

Hemstrought's MiniMoon Cookies

$9.00

( / )

Orange and Vanilla Buttercream Cookies
Quick view

Original SunUp Cookies

$15.00

( / )

VANILLA ON VANILLA BUTTERCREAM COOKIES
Quick view

Vanilla On Vanilla Halfmoons

$15.00

( / )

CHOCOLATE ON VANILLA BUTTERCREAM COOKIES
Quick view

Vanilla On Chocolate Halfmoons

$15.00

( / )

Quick view

Chocolate On Vanilla Halfmoons

$15.00

( / )

HEMSTROUGHT'S HALFMOON COOKIES
Quick view

Chocolate On Chocolate Halfmoons

$15.00

( / )

CANILLA AND COCONUT BUTTERCREAM COOKIE
Quick view

Vanilla & Coconut on Vanilla Halfmoons

$15.00

( / )

VANILLA AND COCONUT BUTTERCREAM COOKIE
Quick view

Vanilla & Coconut On Chocolate Halfmoons

$15.00

( / )

Invalid Password
Enter

Stay In Touch

Become a HALFMOON INSIDER CLUB member and get exclusive offers, new flavors and more sweet surprises first!

SHIPPING INFORMATION

We Ship Monday - Thursday.

Orders are shipped 2-3 day depending on the delivery location.

CONTACT US

315.735.3311

900 Oswego Street
Utica, NY 13502

EMAIL US

admin@hemstroughts.com

STORE HOURS OF OPERATION

Monday - Friday 6:30 AM - 4:00 PM
Saturday  8 AM - 4 PM
Sunday    8 AM - 2 PM

  • © 2025, Hemstroughts Bakery (Est. 1920)
  • Powered by Shopify